Ring Class Action Lawsuit 2026: Payouts and Claims

LawFold
Updated: May 23, 2026 |
548 Views

The ring class action lawsuit is one of the biggest consumer privacy cases in recent years. Ring, the Amazon-owned home security company, agreed to pay $5.8 million to settle FTC charges tied to unauthorized surveillance and lax security practices.

If you owned a Ring device between 2015 and 2023, you could be owed money. This article breaks down every detail you need for 2026: who qualifies, how much you might receive, and how to actually file your claim.

More than 55,000 customers had their private video footage accessed without consent. That number still shocks people. Here is everything you need to know to protect your rights and get compensated.

You will learn about the FTC settlement, private class actions, payout estimates, eligibility rules, filing deadlines, and claim status updates for 2026.


Ring Class Action Lawsuit

The ring class action lawsuit refers to multiple legal actions filed against Ring LLC over serious privacy and security failures. At its core, the case alleges that Ring allowed employees and contractors to access customers’ private video feeds without permission.

The FTC filed a formal complaint in May 2023, accusing Ring of violating consumer trust on a massive scale. The complaint detailed how Ring failed to implement basic security measures, leaving thousands of accounts vulnerable.

This was not a minor oversight. Ring’s own employees reportedly watched intimate moments inside people’s homes. The company also allegedly shared video data with third parties without proper user consent.

DetailInfo
Primary DefendantRing LLC (Amazon subsidiary)
Lead Regulatory BodyFederal Trade Commission
Complaint FiledMay 2023
Core AllegationsUnauthorized access, weak security, privacy violations
Settlement Amount$5.8 million

Several private class action lawsuits were filed alongside the FTC action. These cases were brought by individual consumers in multiple states. Some targeted Ring directly, while others named Amazon as a co-defendant.

The legal theory behind these cases centers on Ring’s broken promises. The company marketed itself as a home security solution. Instead, it became a privacy risk for the very people it claimed to protect.


Ring Class Action Lawsuit 2026

The ring class action lawsuit in 2026 is in its claims distribution phase. Most of the legal heavy lifting is done, and now the focus is on getting money to affected consumers.

The FTC finalized its settlement order in 2023, and claims processing continued through 2024 and 2025. By early 2026, the claims administrator began reviewing eligible submissions and calculating individual payout amounts.

Ring class action lawsuit 2026 blog banner with doorbell icon and legal symbols

If you already submitted a claim, your payment could arrive anytime between Q1 and Q3 of 2026. The exact timeline depends on the total number of valid claims and any remaining objections.

For people who have not yet filed, the window may still be open. Some class action settlements allow late claims up to a certain point. Check your eligibility status through the official settlement website (search “Ring FTC settlement claim” to find the administrator’s page).

  • The settlement fund totals $5.8 million
  • Claims were accepted starting in late 2023
  • Distribution is expected to begin or continue in 2026
  • Late claims may be accepted on a case-by-case basis

This year is your best shot at receiving payment. Once the fund is fully distributed, it’s gone.


Ring Doorbell Lawsuit

The Ring doorbell lawsuit specifically targets Ring’s popular Video Doorbell product line. This is the device most commonly associated with the privacy violations at the center of the case.

Ring Video Doorbells were the company’s flagship product. Millions of Americans installed them at their front doors, trusting Ring to keep their footage private and secure.

The FTC found that Ring doorbell users were especially vulnerable. Weak default security settings meant that hackers could access doorbell camera feeds with minimal effort. Some users reported strangers speaking to them through their own doorbell speakers.

Ring Doorbell ModelAffected PeriodKnown Issues
Video Doorbell (1st Gen)2015 to 2020No two-factor authentication by default
Video Doorbell 22017 to 2020Shared credentials vulnerability
Video Doorbell 32019 to 2021Third-party data sharing concerns
Video Doorbell Pro2017 to 2021Employee access to live feeds

Ring doorbell owners form the largest group of potential claimants. If you purchased any Ring doorbell between 2015 and 2023, you are likely part of the affected class.

The lawsuits argued that Ring marketed the doorbell as a safety device while failing to provide the most basic digital protections. That contradiction sits at the heart of this case.

Key Takeaway: The Ring class action lawsuit covers multiple legal actions against Ring LLC, with the 2026 phase focused on distributing the $5.8 million FTC settlement fund to doorbell and camera owners affected by privacy failures.


Ring Camera Lawsuit

The Ring camera lawsuit extends beyond doorbells to include Ring’s full lineup of indoor and outdoor cameras. Products like the Ring Indoor Cam, Stick Up Cam, and Spotlight Cam are all part of the affected product range.

Indoor camera users faced some of the most disturbing privacy violations. The FTC complaint detailed instances where Ring employees accessed indoor camera feeds in bedrooms, bathrooms, and children’s rooms.

One former employee allegedly viewed thousands of video clips from female customers’ cameras over several months. Ring’s internal controls were so weak that this behavior went undetected for an extended period.

  • Ring Indoor Cam: Most privacy-sensitive due to placement inside homes
  • Ring Stick Up Cam: Used both indoors and outdoors; affected by same security gaps
  • Ring Spotlight Cam: Outdoor use, but still subject to unauthorized employee access
  • Ring Floodlight Cam: Included in the broader class of affected devices

The camera lawsuit is particularly significant because indoor cameras capture the most private moments of people’s lives. These aren’t just recordings of a front porch. They show families eating dinner, kids playing, and people in their most vulnerable states.

If you used any Ring camera between 2015 and 2023, your footage may have been compromised. That makes you a potential claimant in this action.


Ring Privacy Lawsuit

The Ring privacy lawsuit centers on Ring’s failure to protect user data and its practice of sharing information without meaningful consent. This goes beyond hacking; it’s about how Ring itself handled your personal information.

Ring allegedly gave law enforcement agencies access to customer video footage without requiring a warrant in many cases. The company’s Neighbors app also facilitated data sharing that users didn’t fully understand when they signed up.

The FTC specifically cited Ring for violating basic privacy principles:

  • Failing to encrypt stored video footage until 2019
  • Not requiring two-factor authentication until pressure mounted
  • Allowing overly broad employee access to customer accounts
  • Sharing user data with third-party researchers and advertisers

Beyond the FTC case, private lawsuits have alleged violations of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and other state privacy laws. These state-level claims could result in separate settlements or jury verdicts.

Privacy ViolationDescriptionTime Period
No encryptionVideos stored without encryption2015 to 2019
No mandatory 2FAAccounts easily hackable2015 to 2019
Employee accessStaff viewed private feeds2017 to 2023
Law enforcement sharingVideo shared without warrants2016 to 2022
Third-party data sharingUser data sent to advertisers2018 to 2023

Think of it this way: you bought a lock for your front door, but the locksmith kept a copy of the key and lent it out to anyone who asked. That’s what Ring did with your video data.


Ring FTC Settlement

The Ring FTC settlement is the $5.8 million agreement between Ring LLC and the Federal Trade Commission, finalized in 2023. This is the primary legal resolution that most consumers will receive money from.

The FTC proposed the settlement after its investigation found that Ring violated the FTC Act by deceiving consumers about its privacy and security practices. The order requires Ring to pay the full settlement amount and implement major security reforms.

Under the terms of the settlement, Ring must:

  • Delete all improperly obtained video data and data products derived from it
  • Implement a comprehensive privacy program with regular third-party audits
  • Submit to 20 years of FTC oversight on its privacy practices
  • Pay $5.8 million into a fund for affected consumers

The FTC settlement is separate from any private class action lawsuits. Some consumers may be eligible for money from both the FTC fund and a private settlement, depending on the claims involved.

FTC Settlement DetailInfo
Total Fund$5.8 million
Regulatory BodyFederal Trade Commission
Settlement Finalized2023
Oversight Period20 years
Required ReformsData deletion, privacy program, audits

This settlement represents one of the FTC’s strongest enforcement actions in the smart home space. It sends a clear signal to other tech companies about the consequences of sloppy privacy practices.

Key Takeaway: The FTC’s $5.8 million settlement with Ring is the primary source of consumer compensation, with payouts expected to be distributed through 2026 alongside mandatory 20-year privacy reforms.


Ring Settlement Payout

The Ring settlement payout is the amount each eligible claimant receives from the $5.8 million FTC fund. Individual payments will vary based on the total number of approved claims and the type of harm each person experienced.

Based on available data, individual payouts are estimated to range between $15 and $100 for most claimants. However, people who can document specific hacking incidents or employee access to their accounts may receive more.

The payout math is straightforward. Take the $5.8 million fund, subtract attorney fees and administrative costs (typically 25% to 35%), and divide the remaining amount among all valid claimants.

Payout ScenarioEstimated Per-Person Amount
50,000 claimants$75 to $85
100,000 claimants$35 to $45
150,000 claimants$20 to $30
Documented hacking victimUp to $500+

The fewer people who file claims, the more each person gets. That’s how every class action works. If only a fraction of eligible users actually submit paperwork, individual checks could be larger than expected.

Settlement payouts are typically sent as checks or direct deposits. The claims administrator handles distribution once the court gives final approval for the payment schedule.

Don’t expect a life-changing windfall. But consider this: you’re getting paid because a company violated your privacy. The money is yours by right.


Ring Lawsuit Payout Amount

The Ring lawsuit payout amount depends on which legal action you’re part of and what type of claim you filed. The FTC settlement and private class actions have different payout structures.

For the FTC settlement, most consumers will receive between $15 and $100. This covers the general class of Ring users whose data was mishandled.

Private class action lawsuits may offer different compensation levels. Some pending cases seek damages for emotional distress, which could increase individual payouts significantly if the cases settle or go to trial.

Quick Facts: Payout Breakdown

  • FTC settlement (general claim): $15 to $100 estimated
  • Documented hacking victim: $100 to $500+
  • Emotional distress claim (private lawsuit): Potentially $1,000+
  • Individual lawsuit (not class action): Varies widely; some claims exceed $10,000

People who experienced the worst violations, like having a hacker speak to their children through a Ring camera, are in a different category entirely. Their damages go beyond a simple data breach.

If you have evidence of a specific incident, such as police reports, screenshots, or communications with Ring support, you should keep those records safe. Documentation strengthens your claim and can push your payout higher.

The total you receive also depends on whether attorney fees are deducted from your share or paid separately from the fund. In most class actions, fees come off the top before distribution.


Ring Data Breach Lawsuit

The Ring data breach lawsuit focuses on the security failures that exposed customer accounts to unauthorized access. This is distinct from the employee misconduct allegations and centers on Ring’s weak cybersecurity infrastructure.

Ring’s systems were breached multiple times between 2019 and 2023. Hackers exploited the lack of two-factor authentication and weak password requirements to access thousands of customer accounts.

In several high-profile incidents, hackers accessed Ring cameras and used the two-way audio feature to harass families. Some incidents involved children being taunted by unknown voices coming from cameras in their bedrooms.

  • Over 3,000 accounts were confirmed compromised in a 2019 breach
  • Ring initially blamed users for using weak passwords
  • The company did not require two-factor authentication until late 2019
  • Credential-stuffing attacks were the primary method used by hackers
Breach IncidentYearAccounts AffectedRing’s Response
First major breach20193,000+Blamed users; added optional 2FA
Continued attacks2020UndisclosedMade 2FA mandatory for new setups
Employee access revelations2021 to 202355,000+Settled with FTC

The data breach lawsuit argues that Ring had a duty to protect customer data and failed at the most basic level. A company selling security products should have the strongest security practices. Ring had some of the weakest.

Key Takeaway: Ring settlement payouts are estimated at $15 to $100 for general claimants, with documented hacking victims potentially receiving $500 or more, while data breach victims have separate claims based on Ring’s weak cybersecurity infrastructure.


Ring Hacking Lawsuit

The Ring hacking lawsuit addresses the terrifying real-world consequences of Ring’s security failures. Families across the country reported strangers accessing their cameras and speaking through the devices.

These were not theoretical risks. Real people had their homes invaded digitally. In one widely reported case from Mississippi, a hacker accessed an 8-year-old girl’s Ring camera and told her he was Santa Claus.

Other victims reported hackers shouting racial slurs, making threats, or watching them silently for extended periods. The psychological impact on these families was severe and lasting.

  • Hackers used credential stuffing (trying leaked passwords from other sites)
  • Ring’s lack of mandatory 2FA made this trivially easy
  • Some hackers posted Ring camera feeds on public forums and podcasts
  • A podcast called “NulledCast” reportedly livestreamed hacked Ring feeds

The hacking lawsuit argues that Ring is liable because it failed to implement industry-standard security measures. Two-factor authentication was widely available technology. Ring chose not to require it, prioritizing ease of setup over user safety.

Hacking Incident TypeFrequencyTypical Victim Impact
Audio harassmentMost commonFear, anxiety, sleep disruption
Silent surveillanceCommonParanoia, feeling violated
Threats and intimidationLess commonSevere distress, police involvement
Public broadcast of feedsRare but documentedHumiliation, lasting trauma

If someone hacked your Ring device, you have a strong claim. These cases carry more weight than general privacy complaints because the harm is direct and personal.


Ring Camera Hacking Class Action

The Ring camera hacking class action consolidates claims from multiple victims who experienced unauthorized access to their cameras. This type of lawsuit groups similar claims together to increase legal efficiency and bargaining power.

Several class actions were filed in 2019 and 2020 across multiple federal courts. These cases were brought by families and individuals who had their Ring cameras hacked and used against them.

The class in these lawsuits typically includes anyone who:

  • Owned a Ring camera or doorbell between 2015 and 2023
  • Experienced unauthorized access to their device
  • Suffered emotional distress or invasion of privacy
  • Was not adequately warned about security vulnerabilities

One of the lead cases was filed in the Central District of California. This case named both Ring LLC and Amazon.com Inc. as defendants, arguing that Amazon bears responsibility as Ring’s parent company.

Class certification is a critical step in these cases. The court must agree that the victims share enough common issues to be treated as a single group. In Ring’s case, the common thread is clear: everyone was harmed by the same security failures.

If you were part of one of these class actions, you don’t need to do anything separately for the FTC settlement. But you should verify whether the private class action has its own separate settlement or is still pending.


Ring Employee Spying Lawsuit

The Ring employee spying lawsuit may be the most disturbing aspect of this entire legal saga. The FTC found that Ring employees and contractors accessed customer video footage for personal reasons, with no legitimate business purpose.

According to the FTC complaint, one Ring employee accessed thousands of video recordings from at least 81 female users over several months. The footage included intimate moments in bedrooms and bathrooms.

Ring’s internal access controls were shockingly inadequate. Employees had broad, largely unrestricted access to customer video feeds. The company did not implement proper access logging or monitoring until after these incidents came to light.

  • A Ring employee watched feeds of female customers for months
  • At least 81 users were specifically targeted by one employee
  • Ring lacked proper access controls and audit trails
  • The company failed to act on internal complaints about employee behavior
Employee Misconduct DetailInfo
Number of targeted users81+ by one employee alone
Type of footage accessedBedrooms, bathrooms, living areas
Duration of unauthorized accessSeveral months
Ring’s initial responseInadequate internal investigation
FTC’s findingRing failed to limit and monitor employee access

This is not a case of a rogue employee acting alone. The FTC found that Ring’s entire system was designed without proper safeguards. Think of it like a bank vault with no locks on the safe deposit boxes. The problem was structural, not just individual.

Key Takeaway: Ring hacking incidents caused real psychological harm to families, while Ring employees accessed private video feeds of at least 81 users for personal purposes, revealing a company-wide failure in access controls and internal oversight.


Ring Amazon Lawsuit

The Ring Amazon lawsuit draws Amazon into the legal picture as Ring’s parent company. Amazon acquired Ring in February 2018 for approximately $1 billion, and plaintiffs argue that Amazon bears direct responsibility for Ring’s privacy failures.

Amazon’s involvement matters for several reasons. As the parent company, Amazon had the resources, expertise, and obligation to ensure Ring met basic security standards. Critics argue Amazon prioritized rapid growth and market dominance over consumer protection.

The FTC’s settlement specifically names Ring LLC, but several private lawsuits have named Amazon.com Inc. as a co-defendant. These cases argue that Amazon exercised control over Ring’s operations and knew about the security deficiencies.

  • Amazon acquired Ring in 2018 for about $1 billion
  • Amazon integrated Ring with Alexa and its broader smart home ecosystem
  • Private lawsuits name Amazon as a co-defendant
  • Amazon’s deep pockets could mean larger settlements or verdicts
Amazon and Ring TimelineEvent
February 2018Amazon acquires Ring for ~$1 billion
2018 to 2019Ring integrated into Amazon ecosystem
2019First major hacking incidents reported
May 2023FTC files complaint and settlement
2024 to 2025Private lawsuits against Amazon proceed
2026Claims distribution and ongoing litigation

Amazon has also faced a separate $25 million FTC settlement related to Alexa and children’s privacy under COPPA. This shows a pattern of Amazon subsidiaries running into privacy trouble with regulators.

The involvement of Amazon significantly increases the potential financial exposure. If private lawsuits against Amazon succeed, the total compensation pool could grow well beyond the $5.8 million FTC settlement.


Ring Lawsuit Eligibility

Ring lawsuit eligibility covers anyone who owned or used a Ring device during the period of the alleged violations. The eligibility criteria vary slightly between the FTC settlement and private class actions.

For the FTC settlement, you are generally eligible if you:

  • Owned or operated a Ring device between January 2015 and March 2023
  • Had a Ring account during that time period
  • Were a U.S. resident
  • Had your account compromised or your data mishandled

You do not need to prove that your specific account was hacked. The FTC settlement covers the broader class of users whose privacy was compromised by Ring’s systemic failures.

Eligibility FactorFTC SettlementPrivate Class Action
Time period2015 to 2023Varies by case
LocationU.S. residentsVaries; some state-specific
Device typeAll Ring cameras and doorbellsAll Ring devices
Proof of harm requiredNo (general class)Often yes (stronger claims)
Must prove hackingNoDepends on case

For private class actions, eligibility may be narrower. Some cases require proof that you experienced a specific incident, such as a hacking event, unauthorized employee access, or data breach notification from Ring.

If you’re unsure whether you qualify, the simplest test is this: did you own a Ring device in the U.S. between 2015 and 2023? If yes, you are very likely eligible for at least the FTC settlement.


Who Qualifies for the Ring Lawsuit

Anyone who owned a Ring device in the United States between 2015 and 2023 likely qualifies for the Ring lawsuit. You do not need to prove your specific device was hacked or that an employee accessed your footage.

The qualifying class is intentionally broad. The FTC recognized that Ring’s security failures put all users at risk, not just those who were directly targeted.

You qualify if:

  • You purchased a Ring Video Doorbell, Ring Indoor Cam, Ring Stick Up Cam, Ring Spotlight Cam, Ring Floodlight Cam, or any other Ring camera product
  • Your purchase was made between January 2015 and March 2023
  • You set up an account and connected the device
  • You are a U.S. resident or were at the time of purchase

You may receive a higher payout if:

  • Your Ring account was compromised by hackers
  • You received a data breach notification from Ring
  • You experienced a documented incident involving unauthorized camera access
  • You filed a police report related to a Ring hacking incident

People who gave Ring cameras as gifts may face a trickier situation. The person who set up the account and connected the device is typically the one who qualifies, not necessarily the person who paid for the product.

If multiple Ring devices were registered to your account, you may have a stronger claim. Each device represents another data point in the privacy violation.

Key Takeaway: Ring lawsuit eligibility is broad, covering all U.S. Ring device owners from 2015 to 2023, with higher payouts available for those who can document specific hacking incidents or unauthorized access to their accounts.


How to File a Ring Class Action Claim

Filing a Ring class action claim is a straightforward process that most people can complete online in under 15 minutes. The claims administrator manages the entire submission process.

Here are the steps to file your claim in 2026:

Step 1: Locate the official settlement claims website. Search for “Ring FTC settlement claim form” to find the administrator’s page.

Step 2: Gather your information. You will need:

  • Your name and current address
  • Email address associated with your Ring account
  • Approximate purchase date and model of your Ring device
  • Any documentation of hacking incidents (optional but helpful)

Step 3: Complete the online claim form. The form asks for basic information about your Ring device ownership and any issues you experienced.

Step 4: Submit your claim and save your confirmation number. You will need this number to check your claim status later.

Filing StepWhat You NeedTime Required
Find claim formInternet access2 minutes
Gather infoPurchase records, email5 minutes
Complete formPersonal and device details5 to 10 minutes
Submit and save confirmationConfirmation number1 minute

If you prefer not to file online, some settlements accept paper claims. Check the administrator’s website for a printable form and mailing address.

Do not pay anyone to file your claim for you. This process is free. Any service charging you a fee to submit a class action claim is likely a scam.


Ring Lawsuit Deadline 2026

The Ring lawsuit deadline in 2026 depends on which legal action you are filing under. Different settlements and lawsuits have different cutoff dates for claim submissions.

For the FTC settlement, the original claims deadline has passed for most categories. However, late claims may still be accepted in early to mid-2026 at the discretion of the claims administrator.

Deadline TypeEstimated DateStatus
FTC settlement initial claim deadline2024 (passed)Closed for standard claims
Late claim acceptanceEarly to mid-2026Possible on case-by-case basis
Private class action deadlinesVaries by caseCheck individual case notices
Objection and exclusion deadlinesTypically passedClosed

If you missed the original deadline, don’t give up immediately. Contact the claims administrator and explain your situation. Some class actions have provisions for late filers, especially if you only recently learned about the settlement.

For private class action lawsuits that are still pending, separate deadlines will be announced if and when those cases settle. Keep an eye on case developments through 2026.

The most important date right now: If you haven’t filed yet, do it as soon as possible. Every day you wait reduces your chances of being included in the payout distribution.


Ring Settlement Claim Status

Your Ring settlement claim status tells you where your submission stands in the review and payment process. You can check your status online using the confirmation number you received when you filed.

As of 2026, claims are in various stages:

  • Received: Your claim has been submitted and is in the queue
  • Under Review: The administrator is verifying your eligibility
  • Approved: Your claim has been accepted; payment is pending
  • Denied: Your claim was rejected (you may be able to appeal)
  • Paid: Your settlement check or direct deposit has been processed
Claim StatusWhat It MeansYour Next Step
ReceivedIn the queueWait for review
Under ReviewBeing verifiedRespond to any requests for info
ApprovedPayment comingEnsure your address is current
DeniedClaim rejectedReview denial reason; consider appeal
PaidMoney sentCheck mail or bank account

If your claim has been stuck in “under review” for months, contact the claims administrator directly. Processing delays are common in large class actions, but extended waits could indicate a problem with your submission.

Make sure your contact information is up to date. If you moved since filing your claim, update your address with the administrator. Unclaimed settlement checks often go to the wrong address and end up returned.

The worst outcome is having an approved claim with no way for the administrator to reach you. Stay reachable.

Key Takeaway: Check your Ring settlement claim status regularly in 2026 using your confirmation number, and keep your mailing address and contact information current to avoid missing your payout.


Frequently Asked Questions

How much money will I get from the Ring class action lawsuit?

Most claimants can expect between $15 and $100 from the FTC settlement.

People who experienced documented hacking incidents may receive $500 or more.

The exact amount depends on total claims filed and your individual circumstances.

Is it too late to file a claim in the Ring settlement in 2026?

The original deadline has passed, but late claims may still be accepted in early to mid-2026.

Contact the claims administrator to ask about late filing options.

Acting quickly gives you the best chance of inclusion.

Does the Ring lawsuit apply to all Ring camera and doorbell models?

Yes, the lawsuit covers all Ring cameras and doorbells sold between 2015 and 2023.

This includes the Video Doorbell, Indoor Cam, Stick Up Cam, Spotlight Cam, and Floodlight Cam.

Any Ring device connected to an account during that period qualifies.

What did Ring do wrong that led to the class action lawsuit?

Ring failed to protect customer privacy by allowing employees to access private video feeds and by not requiring two-factor authentication.

The FTC found that Ring’s security practices were deceptive and inadequate.

Hackers also exploited Ring’s weak protections to access thousands of customer accounts.

How long does it take to receive a Ring settlement payout?

Settlement payments typically take 6 to 12 months after claim approval to arrive.

For the Ring FTC settlement, payouts are expected throughout 2026.

Processing times vary based on the number of claims and administrative review speed.


The Ring class action lawsuit is a rare case where consumers can hold a major tech company accountable for violating their privacy. If you owned a Ring device between 2015 and 2023, you likely qualify for compensation.

File your claim as soon as possible if you haven’t already. Check your claim status if you have. Stay updated on any new settlement announcements through 2026.

Your home security camera should protect you, not betray you. Make sure you get what you’re owed.

Share
LawFold

Owen Parker

Owen Parker, Esq. is a U.S.-based attorney specializing in civil litigation and personal injury law. He is known for his strategic approach, strong advocacy, and commitment to achieving favorable outcomes for his clients. Owen provides clear legal guidance and dedicated representation in every case he handles.